Narrow screen masthead
Masthead
  • About us
  • Stories
  • Diseases & Vaccines
    • Diseases
    • Vaccines for me
    • Glossary
  • FAQ
  • 10th Anniversary
  • Videos & Resources
    • Videos
    • Useful sites
  • Contact us
  • Viewallstories
    • Interview: How COVID reshaped attitudes to vaccination

      Interview: How COVID reshaped attitudes to vaccination

      Diphtheria is back

      Diphtheria is back

      To restore vaccination rates, we must focus on trust

      To restore vaccination rates, we must focus on trust

      Tick season: How to protect yourself

      Tick season: How to protect yourself

      The race to end HPV ‒ by vaccinating boys and girls

      The race to end HPV ‒ by vaccinating boys and girls

      Child’s play: schools roll out Immune Patrol educational game

      Child’s play: schools roll out Immune Patrol educational game

      Can vaccination reduce the burden of lung disease?

      Can vaccination reduce the burden of lung disease?

      Measles ‘surge’: cases increase tenfold in EU

      Measles ‘surge’: cases increase tenfold in EU

      Can pharmacists accelerate HPV vaccine uptake and help eliminate cervical cancer?

      Can pharmacists accelerate HPV vaccine uptake and help eliminate cervical cancer?

      Can the EU lead the global fight against infectious disease?

      Can the EU lead the global fight against infectious disease?

      EU concerned about misinformation amid disease outbreaks

      EU concerned about misinformation amid disease outbreaks

      US measles death: Is Europe protected?

      US measles death: Is Europe protected?

      Meet the cancer survivor turning his brush with death into a superpower

      Meet the cancer survivor turning his brush with death into a superpower

      COVID-19 vaccines reduce the risk of ‘long COVID’

      COVID-19 vaccines reduce the risk of ‘long COVID’

      Poland is prioritising disease prevention at all ages

      Poland is prioritising disease prevention at all ages

      Are new TB vaccines finally within reach?

      Are new TB vaccines finally within reach?

      HPV vaccination: preventing cervical cancer in Romania

      HPV vaccination: preventing cervical cancer in Romania

      US measles death: child dies in Texas

      US measles death: child dies in Texas
      View all stories
  • Related stories
    • Related stories

      WHO Chief worried about public attitudes to vaccination

      WHO Chief worried about public attitudes to vaccination

      Vaccine safety: perceptions and the internet

      Vaccine safety: perceptions and the internet

Sponsored by

Vaccines Europe

Social media shifting vaccines conversation

Gary Finnegan

Gary Finnegan

December 9th, 2011

Gary Finnegan
Share

‘The era of ‘Big Media’ setting the agenda for discussion on vaccination has been replaced by a more diverse, decentralised online conversation.’

This post was published on December 9, 2011 and may be out of date

Social-media-shifting-vaccines-conversation
Brian Deer
, the investigative journalist whose work highlighted fraud by Andrew Wakefield, said the media environment has changed considerably since the now-debunked link between MMR and measles first spread in the late 1990s.

Deer, who also investigated controversies over other vaccines in the 1980s, said the influence of big newspapers and television channels has been diluted.

“During the DTP controversy, big media would shout ‘scare’ and that was that. They decided the terms of the debate. We’re not in that environment anymore. There is now a marketplace of people searching desperately for information. In some cases they find websites which sound official but have questionable merit. Things have changed and this must be addressed,” he told a meeting hosted by the Fondation Merieux which examined public engagement with vaccination policy. 

Deer has twice won British Press Awards for his investigation into false claims by Andrew Wakefield that the MMR vaccine was connected with the onset of autism. He said the story behind the MMR scare was about power and vested interests, making it fertile ground for investigative journalism.

However, Deer acknowledged that alarmist narratives about vaccination were also appealing to newspapers because they are easy to produce: they are cheap, they stoke primal fears and their stories typically feature sympathetic figures such as children and concerned parents.

There will, he added, be more concerns about vaccination – as vaccination scepticism is as old as immunisation and news media works in cycles – but the changing media landscape offers an opportunity for a new kind of conversation. 

Read: Vaccines do not cause autism


Shifting the mindset

The role of social media was addressed in detail by Philip Weiss, Chief Hyperthinker at e-communications agency, ZN. (Disclosure: ZN worked with EVM to develop Vaccines Today)

He said tools like Twitter had sparked a communications revolution. “If you believe that information is power. And if you believe that the Internet is the ultimate source of information. The logical conclusion is that the Internet is power; the power to shape perceptions. Technology is playing an increasingly critical role in the way we think.”

Weiss said that the people who understood this “first and best” were non-governmental organisations (NGOs) who embraced social media, not least because it is so cost-effective. 

“They became very good at using new media and figured out that, in fact, it works even better than traditional communications. It gets the message out but it also gets people involved. Now they have become highly professional at moving stories and perceptions on critical issues,” he said.

‘H1N1’ was a game-changer

Online discussion about the H1N1 pandemic dominated social media channels in 2009 and this phenomenon has had a profound impact on perceptions of all immunisation programmes. Weiss said public health authorities, academics and companies interested in public health should radically reassess their online communication strategies.

One of the strengths of anti-vaccine campaigners, he said, is that “you see people, faces”. Parents with genuine questions about immunisation are inclined to relate more readily to real people rather than scientific statements issued by faceless institutions.

“We need a new mindset based on real openness and real transparency. Once you go online and start this discussion there’s no stopping. Everyone who is serious about moving the needle on this issue needs to start learning and try different things,” said Weiss.

(See Philip Weiss’ presentation here)

From broadcast to engagement

Clare Matterson, Director, Medical Humanities & Engagement at the Wellcome Trust, told the meeting that science in general had suffered a “crisis of trust”.

In the past decade, she said, scientists and health advocates have moved away from the idea that it was sufficient to fire information at the public and expect it to stick. “Engagement” is the watchword for those interested in communicating on scientific subjects, she said.

This can be done online or through innovative forums such as café scientifique, the Science Media Centre in the UK, Dublin’s Science Gallery, and the Wellcome Trust-sponsored ‘I’m a scientist, get me out of here’ competition.

“The last 10 years has been a time of great experimentation in public engagement with science. We believe engagement is about conversations rather than transmission,” she said.

Read: What can social media tell us about vaccination rates?


Read: Twitter: the new flu-tracking tool


Read Tweets from the Fondation Meriux conference using the #vaxpolicy hashtag

RELATED STORIES

Trustworthy information: Pinterest & Vaccine Safety Net join forces

August 28, 2019

France measles outbreak: babies hit hardest

November 7, 2018

Comment

  1. VaccinesToday (@VaccinesToday) (@VaccinesToday) (@VaccinesToday) (@VaccinesToday)

    VaccinesToday (@VaccinesToday) (@VaccinesToday) (@VaccinesToday) (@VaccinesToday)

    December 9th, 2011

    Social media shifting vaccines conversation http://t.co/HNw5aU02 via @vaccinestoday #hcsmeu #hcsm

Next

Share

Share story

Previous

© Copyright 2022, All Rights Reserved.

Guiding principles

Privacy policy

© Copyright 2022, All Rights Reserved.

VaccinesToday
Manage Cookie Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}
  • Home
  • About us
  • Stories
  • Diseases & Vaccines
    • Diseases
    • Vaccines for me
    • Glossary
  • FAQ
  • 10th Anniversary
  • Videos & Resources
    • Videos
    • Useful sites
  • Contact us